From clay and slate roofing to metal and asphalt, most homeowners consider cost and installation when deciding. Some roofing materials are better for pitched roofs, while others perform better on flat roofs.
For most homeowners seeking cost-effectiveness and durability, asphalt shingles VS metal roof cost may be the determining factor. Are metal roofs cheaper than shingles? The right answer requires careful consideration of various factors presented below.
Cost Comparison
When comparing the cost of metal roof VS shingle roof, let’s explore the differences between the costs in the long run, for expected repairs and durability and the initial investment.
Initial Costs
Initial shingles vs metal roof cost show significant price variations per square foot. Initial shingles vs metal roof cost show significant price variations per square foot. Here is a simple cost of metal roof vs asphalt shingles comparison table:
| Asphalt Shingle Quality | Material Cost per square foot | Installation Cost per square foot | Total Cost per square foot |
| Basic | $1 – 2$ | $2.5 – 3.5$ | $3.5 – 5.5$ |
| Mid-range | $2 – 4$ | $3.5 – 4.5$ | $5.5 – 8.5$ |
| Premium | $4 – 6+$ | $3.5 – 4.5$ | $7.5 – 10+$ |
Are metal roofs more expensive than shingles, most contractors will agree that metal roofs will cost you more money. However, the average price difference is calculated based on the type of metal roofing.
| Metal roof type | Material Cost per square foot | Installation Cost per square foot | Total Cost per square foot |
| Aluminum | $3 6$ | $4 – 5$ | $7 – 11$ |
| Steel (Galvanized) | $2.5 – 4$ | $4 – 6$ | $6.- 10$ |
| Steel (Galvalume) | $3.5 – 5$ | $4 – 6$ | $7.5 – 11$ |
| Copper | $9 – 14$ | $6 – 8$ | $15 – 22$ |
| Zinc | $6 – 8$ | $5 – 7$ | $11 – 15$ |
Long-Term Costs
When determining the long-term metal roof vs shingles price, you have to consider several important roof features:
- Lifespan and Durability
Therefore, you may need sooner replacement if you opt for asphalt roofs with a lifespan between 15 and 30 years. It may cost you equal to or even more money than some other roofs, such as metal, for the same time period and weather conditions. Metal roofs last from 40 to 70 years.
- Maintenance and Repairs
Metal roofs require less maintenance and only additional inspection for loose fasteners or cleaning. On the other hand, asphalt shingles need regular maintenance, shingles repair, or replacement, especially after harsh weather. In the long run, asphalt shingles may cost you more money for frequent repairs or replacements.
- Energy Efficiency
When it comes to metal roof vs shingles comparison on their energy efficiency properties, metal roofs are unparalleled. They reduce energy costs because of the reflective surface.
- Resale Value
Current trends in the roofing industry show that metal roofs increase the resale value of the property. Therefore, if you are considering one major investment before you sell your property, investing in a modern and high-quality roof might be the appropriate step.
Factors Influencing Cost
Important factors, such as material quality and your roof design significantly affect the total cost of your roof replacement.
Material Type and Quality
You can choose between basic 3-tab shingles, architectural, and luxury shingles based on your budget and feature preferences. The basic shingles are the most affordable, but they also come with the shortest lifespan.
If you are interested in metal roofing, a deep analysis of the material-specific features will help you determine the best value for the money. For example, an aluminum roof is expensive, but it has high rust-resistant properties. Steel roof is mid-range, strong, and durable but requires coating to prevent rust. Lastly, copper is the most expensive, but also the most durable roof.
Therefore, once you set the budget for your roof replacement, discuss the material with your contractor to ensure you are getting the most for your money.
Roof Complexity:
Roof complexity determines which material will perform the best as well as the complexity of the required installation. Here is what increases roof costs:
- Steep angles – More labor, advanced safety measures, and more time is needed for proper installation
- Roof’s components – Dormers, skylights, etc., need precise cutting and fitting, which adds to the cost.
- Complex roof designs – Need more time and skills, so roofing companies charge extra for both metal and asphalt shingle roof installation
Installation Costs
Whichever metal roof type you choose, it will require experienced and skilled roofers for installation. Specialized installation, increases the overall costs of the roof and increases the cost difference between metal vs shingle roofing cost.
Asphalt shingles, whatever quality you choose, can be installed in a day, without some challenges and specific considerations.
In addition, the existing roof conditions may also increase the costs if the old roof removal is complex or reveals property structural issues, which need to be addressed before new roof installation.
Geographical Location
Across the US, variations for metal roof compared to shingles, for mid-size homes are significant:
- Asphalt shingles – $5,000 -$12,000
Cost per Square Foot – $3.50 – $5.50
- Metal Roofs – $10,000 – $25,000
Cost per square foot $7.50 – $12
Geographical location affects labor rates and material availability. In urban areas you’ll pay more money for installation, and you’ll have a wider range of available materials.
There are also more contractors available for roof replacement, so selecting a reliable contractor might be challenging.
Pros and Cons
Since budget isn’t the only factor you should consider for your roof, let’s explore the important features, advantages, and disadvantages of asphalt and metal roofs.
Asphalt Shingles
Asphalt shingles are the most widely spread type of roofing. Its cost-effectiveness and various excellent features make it the number one for homeowners looking for solid roof solutions.
- Less money needed for material and installation
- Simple and fast installation
- Excellent availability
- Great range of styles and colors
However, asphalt shingles have drawbacks as well:
- Shorter lifespan
- The roof requires consistent maintenance
- Less energy-efficient
- Roof can be damaged in severe weather
Metal Roofs
The roofing industry is developing with modern materials tailored to address the needs of special weather conditions and aesthetic preferences. Metal roofs are versatile, and not only suitable for commercial properties, like they have been in the past. Their benefits include:
- Durability
- Simple maintenance
- Excellent energy-efficiency
- Environmentally-friendly
- Weather resistant
Their drawbacks are:
- Higher initial costs
- The complex installation requires specialized contractors
- High noise levels during storms if there isn’t insulation
- Prone to denting or scratches during storms
- Aesthetics – the industrial appearance of metal roofs doesn’t suit all homes and properties.
- Susceptible to expansion and contractors during dramatic temperature changes which may cause fasteners to get loose
Overall, despite their cons, metal roofs are favored by people who prefer modern and minimalist home designs. Some drawbacks, such as noise levels, can easily be mitigated with proper insulation, and occasional inspections can prevent expansion and contractors from compromising the roof by securing all loose fasteners. Other than that, metal roofs require minimal upkeep.
Conclusion
Are metal roofs expensive? Installing a metal roof is a significant investment for your home, but it will pay off in the long run and can bring so many benefits to your home, including a modern appearance, increased resale value, and excellent weather protection.
You may opt for an asphalt roof, which is cheaper option, but expect to be ready for more complex maintenance and sooner repairs.
FAQ
Is metal roof cheaper than shingles?
No compared to asphalt shingles, metal roofs cost more money for material and installation.
Do metal roofs require complex maintenance?
No, in fact, metal roofs require simple to zero maintenance and less frequent repairs. Occasionally inspect the roof for loose fasteners and remove debris after a storm.
What will save more energy – metal roof or asphalt shingles?
Metal roofs are energy efficient, especially standing seam metal roofs. It has excellent reflectivity and cool coating, so it reduces the costs for air conditioners and improves the overall energy efficiency of your home. Ventilation is excellent, so the attic temperatures are reduced.
What is more environmentally friendly – metal roof or asphalt roof?
Metal roofs are recyclable, have a longer lifespan, and less waste compared to asphalt roofs. Even though you can recycle some types of asphalt shingles, they still degrade the environment because their production involves petroleum.
What are the most significant factors affecting metal roof cost vs shingles?
Material costs and installation complexity determine the price difference between metal and asphalt roofs. Material for metal roofs is expensive and the installation is more complex and pricey.
